Wednesday, February 13, 2013

Bible ‘Contradictions’ Explained (Samuel, Kings, Chronicles)




MANY Muslims are quick to judge the Bible for its “contradictions” and even enumerate at least 100 examples. Sadly, most, if not all, of their “exposes” against the Christian Sacred Scriptures are wrong information that they learned from equally less informed people.

 If only they stop to think, they would notice that many of the “contradictions” that they cite arise from a comparison of 1 and 2 Samuel, 1 and 2 Kings with 1 and 2 Chronicles.

Among the allegedly conflicting verses most cited are verses with NUMERICAL DIFFERENCES and / or DIFFERENCES in DETAILS.

Examples are:
1.      2Samuel 10:18 vs 1Chronicles 19:18 (Number of Charioteers killed by the Israelites: 700 or 7,000?)
2.      2 Samuel 24:1 vs 1Chronicles 21:1 (Who incited David to count the Israelites: God or Satan?)
3.      2Samuel 24:13 vs 1Chronicles 21:12 (The number of years of plague: 7 or 3?)

It would be understandable for most to not understand the differences in such verses; only a small percentage of Christians or Bible believers know much about Biblical history and proper interpretation.

What is unacceptable are Muslims who insist on attacking the Bible amid their gross lack of knowledge and understanding of what they are criticizing. One Muslim even bragged that “Little learning is dangerous.” Well, he should look in the mirror while he is saying that.

Concerning the Bible, many Muslims are blind being led by the blind. The Lord Jesus asks in Luke 6:39, “Can the blind lead the blind? Will they not both fall into a pit?” As things stand, Muslims are piled 10 persons deep in this vast pit of error.

What is saddening is that these “blind” Muslims are pulling many innocent Christians into that pit as they use their erroneous knowledge in converting people to Islam.

But there is hope for all who seek truth and understanding. There are completely good and valid reasons why there are differences between 1 and 2 Samuel, 1 and 2 Kings and 1 and 2 Chronicles. But, as I see it, the reasons can be summed up in one general idea: DIFFERENCES in the POINTS OF VIEW of the AUTHORS of these books.

1 and 2 Samuel and 1 and 2 Kings were written with a more HISTORICAL PERSPECTIVE, while
1 and 2 Chronicles were written from the RELIGIOUS POINT of VIEW of a PRIEST.

The writing of the four preceding books were in a STRAIGHT-FORWARD, HISTORICAL MANNER, dealing with how God worked or moved among His chosen people, the Israelites.  It is vital for us to know that for the Israelites HISTORY and RELIGION are NOT SEPARATE: God is the Lord and Master of Israel’s HISTORY. (A view that Christians, specifically Catholics, share)

That is why, for example, 2 Samuel 24:1 says that God was the one who incited David into making a census of his people. The text says,

“Again the anger of the LORD was kindled against Israel, and he incited David against them, saying, "Go, count the people of Israel and Judah."

For the Israelites, EVERYTHING that HAPPENS is the WORK of GOD. So, in 2Samuel 24:1, it is stated that GOD was the one who incited David. God might not have been the one who DIRECTLY incited David, but since He allowed it to happen, then the prodding of David was attributed to God.

On the other hand, the writer of 1 and 2 Chronicles (believed to be EZRA, the PRIEST), saw that event from a DIFFERENT PERSPECTIVE or POINT OF VIEW. So, when the Spirit of God inspired him to write, he wrote it from a PRIEST’S PERSPECTIVE, which is from a RELIGIOUS POINT OF VIEW.

And because the human author (God is the PRIMARY AUTHOR) of 1Chronicles KNEW that it was NOT REALLY GOD who ACTED (God only ALLOWED IT), he narrated the same event in 2 Samuel 24:1 from a MORE SPIRITUAL PERSPECTIVE.

That is why in the account of 1Chronicles 21:1, the author pointed out that it was SATAN who ACTUALLY incited David. And that was AFTER GOD ALLOWED HIM to do so.

1Chronicles 21:1
Satan stood up against Israel, and incited David to count the people of Israel.

The understanding that it was Satan who actually acted can be supported by another incident in the Bible—the test that was received by Job.

In the Book of Job, this faithful servant of God was tested: his properties were lost, his loved ones were killed and he even had serious illnesses.

We read in Job 1:21 who he attributes this test. He attributes it to God.

Job 1:21
He said, "Naked I came from my mother's womb, and naked shall I return there; the LORD GAVE, and the LORD HAS TAKEN AWAY; blessed be the name of the LORD."

But was it REALLY GOD who tested him and who TOOK AWAY everything that he had?

No. It was Satan.

To understand this, we go back to Job 1:8, where God talks to Satan about Job.

The LORD said to Satan, "Have you considered my servant Job? There is no one like him on the earth, a blameless and upright man who fears God and turns away from evil."

To that, Satan retorted (Job 1:9-11):

Does Job fear God for nothing? Have you not put a fence around him and his house and all that he has, on every side? You have blessed the work of his hands, and his possessions have increased in the land. But stretch out your hand now, and touch all that he has, and he will curse you to your face."

Satan was claiming that Job was only faithful because God had given him wealth and security.

To prove to Satan that Job was a true and faithful servant, God ALLOWED Satan to test him.

Job 1:12
The LORD said to Satan, "Very well, all that he has is in your power; only do not stretch out your hand against him!"
So Satan went out from the presence of the LORD.

Satan then began testing Job.

WHO went out to test Job?

Satan.

But then, to whom did Job attribute the test?

To God.

Thus, we see in this story the two points of view that we are discussing in relation to the “contradiction” between 2 Samuel 24:1 vs 1Chronicles 21:1:

·         2 Samuel 24:1 relates to Job 1:21, where the ACTION is ATTRIBUTED to GOD. He allowed it, so it was said the HE “DID” IT.
·         Meanwhile, 1 Chronicles 21:1 relates to Job 1:8-12, where God ALLOWS some things to happen, but it is SATAN who ACTUALLY DOES the ACTION.

NO CONTRADICTION, ONLY A DIFFERENCE IN POINT OF VIEW.
And the same can be said in MOST of the other supposed “contradictions” that Muslims claim against the Bible.

Other examples are:

1.      2Samuel 10:18 vs 1Chronicles 19:18 (Number of Charioteers killed by the Israelites: 700 or 7,000?). 2Samuel 10:18 counted the number of CHARIOTS. 1Chronicles counted the number of MEN manning the chariots (700 chariots x 10 men = 7,000).

2.      2Samuel 24:13 vs 1Chronicles 21:12 (The number of years of plague: 7 or 3?). Seven is the HISTORICAL number of years. Three refers to the COMPLETION of God’s punishment on Israel, the RELIGIOUS PERSPECTIVE.

3.      1Kings 4:26 vs 2Chronicles 9:25 (Number of stalls 40,000 or 4,000). The 40,000 of 1Kings includes stalls in Israel and Judea. (See 1Kings 4:25) The 4,000 of 2Chronicles counts only those in Judea. (The Chronicler was interested only in Judea, where the temple was)

So, most if not ALL of the criticisms of Muslims about supposed “contradictions” in the Bible are due to a GROSS LACK of KNOWLEDGE and UNDERSTANDING of the history and context of the books of Scriptures. To believe them is to be MISLED by FALSE claims.

Sadly, so many have fallen victim to such blindness.

Thursday, February 7, 2013

QURAN: Hindi "Book" ang Ibinigay ayon sa Muslim



ITO ang DAHILAN kung bakit LUMABAS ang KAGASPANGAN ng UGALI ng Muslim na si MANDI ABDULLAH sa FACEBOOK nitong FEBRUARY 8, 2013.

NAGWAWALA SIYA roon at naging DAHILAN ng PAGKA-TANGGAL NIYA.


Ang BACKGROUND NITO ay ITINATANONG KO sa KANYA kung "BOOK" ang IBINIGAY sa mga MUSLIM. SINASABI kasi sa QURAN na "BOOK" daw ang IBINIGAY sa KANILA.

Halimbawa, Quran 3:7, " It is He Who has sent down to you (Muhammad صلى الله عليه وسلم) the Book (this Qur'an)..."

MALINAW riyan na "BOOK" daw ang "SENT DOWN" sa PROPETA NILANG si MUHAMMAD. MABABASA rin iyan sa may 70 TALATA sa QURAN. "BOOK" daw TALAGA ang IBINIGAY sa KANILA.

Pero BASAHIN NINYO ang 10 POINTS na IBINIGAY ng MUSLIM na si MANDI ABDULLAH at MAKIKITA NINYONG KINOKONTRA NIYA ang SABI ng QURAN.

PINALALABAS NIYA na HINDI "BOOK" ang NATANGGAP ng mga MUSLIM.

+++

QURAN PROVEN NOT TRUE by MUSLIM
(BOOK MADE ONLY BY MEN; NOT GIVEN BY GOD)
.
.
MUSLIM Mandi Abdullah posted ANOTHER EXPLANATION of the QURAN that only PROVED that GOD NEVER GAVE a "BOOK."

Following is the POST of MANDI ABDULLAH and MY COMMENTS inserted in between HIS POINTS:

TEN POINTS OF UNDERSTANDING QURAN'S REVELATION

1st - and foremost, as mentioned in another answer, the prophet, peace be upon him, did not read or write. Therefore, it was be impossible for him to write the Quran.
Second, the word actually has the meaning of "recitation" or "reciting" something. Therefore, it doesn't make sense to say, "Who 'wrote' it". It should be, "Who 'recited' it?"
The "Recitation of Quran" was first heard by Muhammad, peace be upon him, from Allah's Angel, Jibril (Gabriel). Then Muhammad, peace be upon him, memorized it and in turn, recited it to his companions and they memorized and recited it to the next generation and that generation memorzied and recited it to the next and so on, until this very day.

CENON BIBE:
Diyan ay MALINAW na WALANG LIBRONG IBINIGAY. Paano magbibigay ng libro kung ang CLAIM ninyo ay "HINDI MARUNONG MAGBASA si MUHAMMAD"?

Kaya nga "RECITATION" daw ang IBINIGAY.

So, ayon kay MANDI ABDULLAH ay MALI ang QURAN na NAGSABING "BOOK" ang IBINIGAY, di ba?

SALAMAT sa BAGONG EXPOSE.

+++

2nd - The companions wrote out their recitings on animal skins, bones of animals and large stones and even on wide palm leaves. These were wriiten down by companions who had memorized the Quran from the recitation they had heard rectied to them. This was called "mushaf" (meaning - written scriptures and is pronounced moos-haf), and was recorded and written down during the prophet's life.

CENON BIBE:
Diyan ay MALIWANAG na MALI ULI at HINDI TOTOO ang SINABI ng QURAN na "BOOK" ang IBINIGAY.

Mga "companions" pa pala ang NAGSULAT, di ba? TAO ang GUMAWA ng UNANG mga "WRITTEN" VERSIONS ng QURAN at HINDI IBINIGAY ng DIYOS.

TAMA?

BAGONG EXPOSE na naman LABAN sa QURAN. SALAMAT.

+++

3rd - The prophet Muhammad, peace be upon him, did ask about a dozen or so of those who memorized Quran from him, to record it. And as mentioned earlier, they did as instructed, writing on various mediums, including animal skins (leather), large rocks, bark and palm leaves.
He then rehearsed it with them over and over - even up until the time of him passing away.

CENON BIBE:
Ayun, PROPETA MUHAMMAD lang pala NINYO ang NAGPASULAT ng QURAN. HINDI IBINIGAY ng DIYOS tulad ng CLAIM ng QURAN, di ba?

PROPETA LANG NINYO ang NAGSABI na GUMAWA ng WRITINGS. Ni HINDI ang DIYOS ang NAGSABI, TAMA?

SALAMAT sa EXPOSE.

+++

4th - Three of the actual Qurans printed in the time of the earliest companions of Muhammad, peace be upon him, exist today and these are exactly as we recite from Quran today.
One is in Tashkent, Uzbekistan museum, another in a museum in England and the last one in the Topkopi Museum in Istanbul, Turkey.

CENON BIBE:
NA-PRINT lang pala ang QURAN nung PANAHON ng mga companion ni MUHAMMAD. HINDI sa PANAHON NIYA.

So, WALA ngang LIBRO na IBINIGAY sa INYO, tulad ng SINASABI sa QURAN.

SALAMAT at LALO MONG IPINAKITA na MALI ang SINASABI ng QURAN.

+++

5th - We are happy to tell you, the Quran was recorded in the hearts and minds of more than 10,000 men and women while the prophet, was still alive.
He rehearsed it over and over with his companions day after day and in its entirety from cover to cover, out loud, every Ramadhan (lunar month of Muslim calendar).

CENON BIBE:
GANUN BA? Sa mga puso ng mga tagasunod na-"record" ang Quran at HINDI TALAGA LIBRO na IBINIGAY.

Grabe, 68 TALATA sa QURAN ang NAGSABI na LIBRO ang IBINIGAY sa mga MUSLIM. Yon pala ay WALA.

NATUTUWA pa ang mga MUSLIM na WALANG LIBRO dahil NASA PUSO raw ang QURAN.

SALAMAT, Mandi. LALO AKONG NALIWANAGAN.

+++

6th - You do not need to worry about honesty and integrity in narration of those people who preserved the Quran in their hearts.
Every one of them was very well known. The honesty and integrity of each and every single one of these people (called companions of the prophet) has been attested to by many authentic narrations and writings. All of them were known for their excellent memorization and they recited and passed on the Quran exactly the same as each other.
These companions and their next generation memorized it the same as people do today. It was always from mouth to ear and in the exact manner of recitation.This is in itself, an amazing thing.
No other book on earth has ever had such distinction in this area.

CENON BIBE:
HINDI naman ang INTEGRIDAD at KATAPATAN ang ISYU e. Ang ISYU ay kung "BOOK" ang IBINIGAY ng DIYOS sa MUSLIM.

Ang 6TH ITEM MO ay NAGPAPATUNAY na HINDI TALAGA BOOK ang IBINIGAY sa INYO.

MALINAW sa POST MO na TAO LANG ang GUMAWA ng "BOOK" ng QURAN. HINDI YAN IBINIGAY ng DIYOS.

So, LALONG LUMINAW na HINDI TOTOO ang SABI ng QURAN na "BOOK" ang IBINIGAY sa INYO.

+++

7th - There is no other book on earth like the Quran. Its style and prose in the Arabic language is unmatched for 14 centuries. The prophecies, predictions, scientific evidences, ease of memorization and ability to comprehend is beyond compare.

CENON BIBE:
Dito ay MALINAW nang HINDI DIYOS ang NAGBIGAY ng "BOOK" ng QURAN.

TAO NA ang PINUPURI RIYAN.

IKAW NA ang NAGPATUNAY na TAO LANG ang GUMAWA ng BOOK na yan.

+++

8th - You can safely put your mind to rest on this subject of preservation of the Holy Quran, because of its presence with us even today, throughout the entire world. Besides the Quran being preserved in museums in Turkey and Uzbekistan, there are those who have it totallly memorzied, by heart.
Today every single living Muslim (over 1 billion) has memorized some portion of the Quran in the original Arabic language that it came in, just as the people memorized it over 1,400 years ago. And amazingly enough, over 9 million men, women and children have the entire Quran in their hearts and can recite it for you from cover to cover.

CENON BIBE:
PRESERVED BA?

IPINASUNOG ni CALIPH UTHMAN ang MGA UNANG QURAN. ANONG PAG-PRESERVE DUN?

Siguro ang na-PRESERVE ay yung GAWA NA ng TAO. Sabagay, WALA namang LIBRO na IBINIGAY ng DIYOS, di ba? AYON MISMO sa IYO ay TAO LANG ang GUMAWA ng LIBRO.

SALAMAT HA

+++

9th - Allah Himself, has promised to preserve the Quran until the Last Days. And He
has, both in book form and in the hearts of so many believers.
Consider this statement - It is the only book on earth that - if you destroyed every book on earth - we would be able to bring it back, exactly as it was, every single letter from cover to cover (by the permission of Allah)
So, these are facts about the Quran and how it was and is, preserved just as Allah has said, in the Quran - That He will preserve it and make it easy to memorize.

CENON BIBE:
OWS? PAANO IPAPANGAKO ng DIYOS na IPI-PRESERVE ang "BOOK" ng QURAN e AMINADO na nga KAYO na WALANG BOOK na IBINIGAY sa INYO?

DUMADAGDAG nang DUMADAGDAG ang KAMALIAN habang HUMAHABA ang PALIWANAG NINYO ah.

Lalabas pa ngayon na NAGSINUNGALING ang DIYOS dahi AALAGAAN daw Niya ang "BOOK" na ayon sa INYO ay HINDI NAMAN NIYA IBINIGAY.

Sige pa. DAGDAG PA ng EXPOSE. MAWAWASAK NA NINYO ang TULUYAN ang QURAN.

+++

10th - You can prove it for yourself, if you doubt.
The Quran of today can be easily checked by Muslims anywhere on the earth. And there can be no doubt in the mind of any Muslim whether or not what is being recited here in Philippines is the same as what is being recited in Arabia or Africa or in the USA for that matter.

CENON BIBE:
ANO ang MATSI-CHECK ng mga MUSLIM? Ang "BOOK" na GAWA LANG ng TAO at HINDI IBINIGAY ng DIYOS?

ANO ang SAYSAY NUN?
.
.
.
MULI, NAPATUNAYAN ng ISANG MUSLIM na HINDI TOTOO ang SINASABI ng QURAN na "BOOK" ang IBINIGAY sa KANILA.

SIYA ang NAGBIGAY ng PROOF na MALI ang QURAN. HINDI TAYO.

SALAMAT.

QURAN EXPOSED: Hindi librong ibinigay ng Diyos



QURAN EXPOSED BY MUSLIM
(Not a BOOK FROM GOD)

NAGPAPASALAMAT tayo kay YUSOF ISLAAM dahil sa POST NIYA na NAGHAHAYAG kung ANO TALAGA ang QURAN.

Ayon sa MUSLIM na si YUSOF: Ang Quran ay "hindi sya isang aklat nahulog sa langit."

NATUMBOK at KINONTRA ni YUSOF ISLAAM ang PAULIT-ULIT na SABI ng QURAN na "BOOK" ang QURAN na IBINIGAY sa mga MUSLIM.

Sabi ni YUSOF ISLAAM: (FACEBOOK FEBRUARY 4, 2013)

ganito: ang qur'an 23 years natanggap ni propht Muhamad, hindi sya isang aklat nahulog sa langit.

verse by verse, chapter by chapter, and the last rmamadhan in his life iya gibasa ang qur'an makalawa...

sala loob ng 23 years may mga shahaba naka memorize more than 100 people, di pa namatay ang rasol

sa panahon ni abu bakr he gathered dffernt records including the memorizers and put to writings
.
.
.
in original understanding, qur'an is not a book...qur'an meaning recitation

qur'an is from the word qara means reading. pag diyan na sa libro ang tawag MUSHAF.

ang qur'an walay revision di gaya ng bible almost evry year ni revised..

sino ang tao mag revised sa word of God? Ang tao ba ay mas maalam kay sa dios bakit nya e revised?
.
.
.
+++

Kung TOTOO ang mga SINABI ni YUSOF ISLAAM ay LUMALABAS na MALI ang mga SUMUSUNOD na AYA ng QURAN.

1. Quran 2:2, "This is the Book (the Qur'an)] ..."

2. Quran 2:89, "... a Book (this Qur'an) from Allah ..."

3. Quran 2:121, "... We have given the Book (the Qur'an)] recite it..."

4. Quran 2:129, "... instruct them in the Book (this Qur'an)..."

5. Quran 2:151, "... teaching you the Book (the Qur'an)..."

6. Quran 2:176, "... Allah has sent down the Book (the Qur'an) in truth."

7. Quran 2:231, "...He has sent down to you of the Book (i.e. the Qur'an)..."

8. Quran 3:3, "It is He Who has sent down the Book (the Qur'an) to you (O Muhammad صلى الله عليه وسلم)...)

9. Quran 3:7, " It is He Who has sent down to you (Muhammad صلى الله عليه وسلم) the Book (this Qur'an)..."

10. Quran 3:119, "... they disbelieve in your book, the Qur'an]..."

11. Quran 3:164, "... instructing them (in) the Book (the Qur'an)..."

12. Quran 4:105, "... Surely, We have sent down to you (O Muhammad صلى الله عليه وسلم) the Book (this Qur'an)..."

13. Quran 4:113, "... Allah has sent down to you the Book (the Qur'an) ..."

14. Quran 4:136, "... the Book (the Qur'an) which He has sent down to His Messenger ..."

15. Quran 4:140, "And it has already been revealed to you in the Book (this Qur'an) ..."

16. Quran 5:15, "... Indeed, there has come to you from Allah a light (Prophet Muhammad صلى الله عليه وسلم) and a plain book (this Qur'an)."

17. Quran 5:48, "And We have sent down to you (O Muhammad صلى الله عليه وسلم) the Book (this Qur'an) in truth..."

18. Quran 6:92, "And this (the Qur'an) is a blessed book which We have sent down..."

19. Quran 6:114, "... it is He Who has sent down unto you the Book (the Qur'an)..."

20. Quran 6:155, "And this is a blessed Book (the Qur'an) which We have sent down ..."

21. Quran 7:2, "(This is the) Book (the Qur'an) sent down unto you (O Muhammad صلى الله عليه وسلم)..."

22. Quran 7:52, "Certainly, We have brought them a Book (the Qur'an)..."

23. Quran 7:196, "... Allah Who has revealed the Book (the Qur'an)..."

24. Quran 10:1, "... These are the Verses of the Book (the Qur'an) Al-Hakim."

25. Quran 12:1, "...the Clear Book (the Qur'an ..."

26. Quran 13:1, "... these are the Verses of the Book (the Qur'an) ..."

27. Quran 14:1, "... (This [Quran] is) a Book which We have revealed unto you (O Muhammad صلى الله عليه و سلم)..."

28. Quran 15:1, "... these are Verses of the Book and a plain Qur'an."

29. Quran 16:64, "And We have not sent down the Book (the Qur'an) to you (O Muhammad صلى الله عليه و سلم) ..."

30. Quran 16:89, "... We have sent down to you the Book (the Qur'an) as an exposition of everything..."

31. Quran 18:1, "... Allah, Who has sent down to His slave (Muhammad صلى الله عليه وسلم) the Book (the Qur'an)..."

32. Quran 18:27, "And recite what has been revealed to you (O Muhammad صلى الله عليه وسلم) of the Book (the Qur'an)..."

33-37. Quran 19:16, 41, 51, 54, 56, "And mention in the Book (the Qur'an,.."

38. Quran 21:10, "Indeed, We have sent down for you (O mankind) a Book (the Qur'an)..."

39. Quran 26:2, "These are the Verses of the manifest Book [(this Qur'an)..."

40. Quran 27:1, "... These are the Verses of the Qur'an, and (it is) a Book..."

41. Quran 28:86, "And you were not expecting that the Book (this Qur'an) would be sent down to you ..."

42. Quran 29:45, "Recite (O Muhammad صلى الله عليه وسلم) what has been revealed to you of the Book (the Qur'an)..."

43. Quran 29:47, "And thus We have sent down the Book (i.e. this Qur'an) to you (O Muhammad صلى الله عليه وسلم)..."

44. Quran 29:48, "Neither did you (O Muhammad صلى الله عليه وسلم) read any Book before it (this Qur'an)..."

45. Quran 29:51, "... We have sent down to you the Book (the Qur'an)..."

46. Quran 31:2, "These are Verses of the Wise Book (the Qur'an)."

47. Quran 32:2, "The revelation of the Book (this Qur'an)..."

48. Quran 35:29, "Verily, those who recite the Book of Allah (this Qur'an)..."

49. Quran 35:31, "And what We have revealed to you (O Muhammad صلى الله عليه وسلم), of the Book (the Qur'an)..."

50. Quran 35:32, "Then We gave the Book (the Qur'an) ..."

51. Quran 38:29, "(This is) a Book (the Qur'an) which We have sent down to you ..."

52. Quran 39:1, "The revelation of this Book (the Qur'an)..."

53. Quran 39:23, "Allah has sent down the Best Statement, a Book (this Qur'an)..."

54. Quran 39:41, "Verily, We have sent down to you (O Muhammad صلى الله عليه وسلم) the Book (this Qur'an) ..."

55. Quran 40:2, "The revelation of the Book (this Qur'an) ..."

56. Quran 40:70, "Those who deny the Book (this Qur'an) ..."

57. Quran 42:15, "... "I believe in whatsoever Allah has sent down of the Book [all the holy Books, - this Qur'an..."

58. Quran 42:17, "It is Allah Who has sent down the Book (the Qur'an) ..."

59. Quran 43:2, "By the manifest Book (i.e. this Qur'an..."

60. Quran 44:2, "By the manifest Book (this Qur'an)..."

61. Quran 45:2, "The revelation of the Book (this Qur'an)..."

62. Quran 46:2, "The revelation of the Book (this Qur'an)..."

63. Quran 46:12, "... And this is a confirming Book (the Qur'an) in the Arabic language..."

64. Quran 46:30, "... we have heard a Book (this Qur'an) sent down after Musa (Moses) ..."

65. Quran 62:2, "... teaching them the Book (this Qur'an, ..."

66. Quran 70:36, "... Allah's Book (this Qur'an)]."

SA mga IYAN ay MALINAW na MABABASA na "BOOK" daw ang IBINIGAY sa mga MUSLIM, bagay na SINASABI ni YUSOF ISLAAM na MALI. HINDI raw BOOK ang IBINIGAY sa kanila.

Ayon kay YUSOF ISLAAM:
"ang qur'an 23 years natanggap ni propht Muhamad, hindi sya isang aklat nahulog sa langit.

"verse by verse, chapter by chapter, and the last rmamadhan in his life iya gibasa ang qur'an makalawa..."

MALINAW na "VERSE BY VERSE, CHAPTER BY CHAPTER" daw IBINIGAY ang QURAN.

Kung ganun ay lalabas na MALING-MALI ang mga VERSE na NABANGGIT sa ITAAS dahil diyan ay TINUKOY na "BOOK" ang IBINIGAY. WALANG SINABI na "VERSE BY VERSE, CHAPTER BY CHAPTER."

So, paano nangyari na SINABING "BOOK" ang IBINIGAY sa mga MUSLIM? Hindi ba lalabas na ni-REVISE YAN o BINAGO?

SASABLAY naman ang SABI ni YUSOF na "ang qur'an walay revision ... sino ang tao mag revised sa word of God? Ang tao ba ay mas maalam kay sa dios bakit nya e revised?"

Ang mga VERSE sa ITAAS na MALINAW na REVISED na ng TAO. NABAGO NA. GINAWA nang LIBRO ang QURAN e WALA pa namang LIBRO HABANG NABUBUHAY si MUHAMMAD e.

Kaya SINASABI ni YUSOF ISLAAM na HINDI WORD OF GOD ang QURAN; REVISED na KASI e.

+++

MARAMING SALAMAT sa PAGLILINAW na GINAWA ni YUSOF ISLAM.

MARAMI ang MAMUMULAT sa KANYANG SINABI.

QURAN: Hindi 'libro' ang ibinigay sa Muslim (1)



MORE QURAN EXPOSE BY MUSLIM
(QURAN HINDI LIBRO KUNDI "READING")

MAY mga BAGONG PASABOG si YUSOF ISLAAM tungkol sa QURAN.

BASAHIN NATIN ang KANYANG MGA POST DITO SA FACEBOOK (FEBRUARY 5, 2013):

SABI MO, Yusof Islaam:
The literal meaning of the Qur'an is reading

CENON BIBE:
Bago ang ANO pa man ay MARAMING SALAMAT sa PAG-AMIN MO na WALANG LIBRO na IBINIGAY sa INYO.

Now, "READING" ba ang QUR'AN?

E di LALABAS na naman na MALI ang SINASABI sa QUR'AN.

Kapag kasi READING ay MAY BINASA. TAMA?

MAY BINASA BA ang PROPETA MUHAMMAD NINYO nung IBIGAY NIYA sa INYO ang QURAN?

WALA, di ba?

So, MALI NA NAMAN ang SABI sa QURAN na "READING" (PAKAHULUGAN na BIGAY MO) ang IBINIGAY sa INYO. WALA naman kasing "BINASA." TAMA?

Muli, SALAMAT at KAYO ang NAGLALANTAD sa mga KAMALIAN sa QURAN.

+++

SABI MO, Yusof Islaam:
, and qur'an maraming name: Kitab (book), Furqan (Criterion), Mushaf. Ngayon pagsabi mo book or libro meaning from cover to cover. But noon and tinatawag na Kitab translated as book is a scroll.

CENON BIBE:
Nag-EXPOSE KA na naman ng BAGONG MALI sa QURAN.

PAANONG matatawag na KITAB (BOOK) ang READING? Ang READING ay AKSYON o VERB. Ang KITAB ay NOUN.

MAGKAIBA, di ba?

MAY KONTRAHAN. MAY MALI.

At ayan pa, SABI MO ay "SCROLL" ang "KITAB."

MERON BANG SCROLL na IBINIGAY sa PROPETA NINYO?

WALA.

So, MALI na NAMAN ang SABI sa QURAN na "KITAB" o "SCROLL" ang IBINIGAY sa INYO.

Kung KITAB o SCROLL ang IBINIGAY e HINDI NA KAILANGANG I-MEMORIZE, di ba? MAY WRITTEN FORM NA e.

KATUNAYAN, ang mga NAKARINIG kay MUHAMMAD ang NAGSULAT.

SABI sa SAHIH HADITH BUKHARI 60:201:
"... So I started locating Quranic material and collecting it from parchments, scapula, leaf-stalks of date palms and from the memories of men (who knew it by heart)...."

Kaya SALAMAT at DINAGDAGAN MO ang PROOF na MALI ang SINASABI sa QURAN.

+++

SABI MO, Yusof Islaam:
Sinulat sa balat (hindi papel). Ngayon nalang bago ay naisulat sa papel...

CENON BIBE:
Ayun, so WALA ngang LIBRO NOON. BALAT, di ba?

NGAYON NA LANG yang PAPEL.

So, BAKIT "LIBRO" ang SINASABI sa QURAN.

E di MALINAW na REVISED NA ang NAKASULAT sa QURAN. HINDI NA YAN yung sinasabi ninyong "WALANG NABAGO."

+++

SABI MO, Yusof Islaam:
Kitab na triinanslate na Book ngayon iba. Kitab the root word is Kataba sa literal na kahulogan sinulat So kahit isang word o isang letra pag naisulat tinawag na kitab, pero ngayon pagsabe mo book may maraming pages. Katab ang ugat sa Kitab na ngayoy tawag na libro ay di mo makuhaan ng pariho ang kahulogan.

CENON BIBE:
AYAN PA. Sabi mo, ang QUR'AN ay "READING." Sabi ng iba ay "RECITATION."

Ngayon naman ay "SINULAT."

ANO ba TALAGA?

KITANG-KITA na MARAMING NABAGO sa QURAN kaya nga KONTRA-KONTRA NA ang SINASABI NINYO tungkol sa QURAN.

Ngayon, ANO BA TALAGA ang "KITAB"? LIBRO, SCROLL o ISANG LETRA LANG?
.
.
.
Sa sinabi mo pa ay LALABAS na MALI na naman ang NASA QURAN. HINDI pala "KITAB" ang TINUTUKOY kundi "KATABA" o "KATAB."

Pero KATABA o KATAB ba ang NAKASULAT o KITAB?

Ayon sa iyo ay "PAREHO" LANG ang mga yan. Kung ganun ay DAPAT ay MAY MABABASA ring "KATABA" o "KATAB" sa ARABIC na QURAN.

Puwede ka ba MAGPAKITA ng "KATABA" o "KATAB" na TRANSLATED as "BOOK"?

Kung WALA ay MALINAW na MALI NA NAMAN YAN sa QURAN.

SALAMAT.

QURAN: Hindi 'libro' ang ibinigay ng Diyos (2)



QURAN EXPOSE 2
(HINDI LIBRO kundi RECITATION)
.
.
.
DINAGDAGAN ni Mandi Abdullah ang EXPOSE ni Yusof Islaam na NAGPAPAKITA ng MALI sa QURAN.

Sa halos 70 TALATA ay SINASABI sa QURAN na "KITAB" o LIBRO ang IBINIGAY sa mga MUSLIM.

Pero AYON KAY MANDI ABDULLAH ay "RECITATION" pala ang IBINIGAY.

SABI NI, Mandi Abdullah
The Quran

Quran Means "Recitation"

The word "Quran" means "that which is recited; or that which is dictated in memory form." As such, it is not a book, nor is it something that reaches us only in written form.
.
.
.
CENON BIBE:
NAGKONTRAHAN NA naman ang mga MUSLIM.

Ang SABI ni Yusof Islaam ay "READING" ang QURAN.

ITO namang si MANDI ABDULLAH ay "RECITATION" DAW.

ANO BA TALAGA?

+++

Anyway, SALAMAT kay MANDI dahil DINAGDAGAN NIYA ang KAMALIAN sa QURAN.

HINDI pala TALAGA "LIBRO" ang IBINIGAY kundi "RECITATION."

So, MALINAW na lalabas na MALI talaga ang QURAN.

HINDI LIBRO. RECITATION DAW.

MARAMING SALAMAT, MANDI ABDULLAH.